| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | OLIVET 15 now wearing 1I. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | OLIVET 1I now wearing 15. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | OLIVET 1I now wearing 8. |
| | | Olivet wins toss, defers. Alma receive and defend north goal. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | OLIVET ball on OLIVET30. |
| | | Kyle Zabel kickoff 50 yards to the ALMA20, Corey McCue return 16 yards to the ALMA36 (Cody Worden). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma36 | Tyler Periard rush for 8 yards to the ALMA44 (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 2-2 | at Alma44 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Matt Brown (Michael Terrano). |
| Alma | 3-2 | at Alma44 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Chad Stripling) 5 yards to the ALMA39. |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Alma39 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Vinny Zanotti) 5 yards to the ALMA34. |
| Alma | 3-12 | at Alma34 | M. McGrady rush for 10 yards to the ALMA44 (Justin Hughes;Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Alma44 | Matt Brown punt 28 yards to the OLIVET28, fair catch by Carl Mulder. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 13:27. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet28 | Nick McCleary rush for 6 yards to the OLIVET34, out-of-bounds (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 3-4 | at Olivet34 | Pat Clasgens rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET36 (Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 4-2 | at Olivet36 | Ryan Patten punt 63 yards to the ALMA1, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma01 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 11:57. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma01 | M. McGrady rush for 1 yard to the ALMA2 (Zach Radtke). |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma02 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Andrew Schaar, QB hurry by Zach Radtke. |
| Alma | 3-9 | at Alma02 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Andrew Schaar, dropped pass. |
| Alma | 4-9 | at Alma02 | Timeout Alma College, clock 11:12. |
| Alma | 4-9 | at Alma02 | Matt Brown punt 47 yards to the ALMA49, Carl Mulder return 2 yards to the ALMA47 (Bart Blystone;Corey McCue). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma47 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 11:01. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma47 | Pat Clasgens rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALMA48 (Brad Collins). |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Alma48 | PENALTY OLIVET false start (Mark VanLente) 5 yards to the OLIVET47. |
| Olivet | 2-16 | at Olivet47 | PENALTY OLIVET false start (Philip Koops) 5 yards to the OLIVET42. |
| Olivet | 2-21 | at Olivet42 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Mike Martin for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET40 (Brent Willis). |
| Olivet | 3-23 | at Olivet40 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Nathaniel Woods for 13 yards to the ALMA47 (Zach Comer), PENALTY OLIVET personal foul (Mark VanLente) 15 yards to the OLIVET38. |
| Olivet | 4-25 | at Olivet38 | 4th and 25. |
| Olivet | 4-25 | at Olivet38 | Ryan Patten punt 44 yards to the ALMA18, fair catch by A.J. Rahar. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 15 yards, TOP 02:35 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma18 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 08:26. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma18 | Tyler Periard rush for 4 yards to the ALMA22, out-of-bounds (Nick Glass;Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 2-6 | at Alma22 | M. McGrady rush for 2 yards to the ALMA24, out-of-bounds (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Alma24 | M. McGrady pass complete to Bruno Gervasi for 8 yards to the ALMA32, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Jared Thornton). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma32 | Tyler Periard rush for loss of 7 yards to the ALMA25 (William Albrech;Chris Gottardo). |
| Alma | 2-17 | at Alma25 | M. McGrady pass complete to Matt Brown for 6 yards to the ALMA31, out-of-bounds (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 3-11 | at Alma31 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Chad Stripling) 5 yards to the ALMA26. |
| Alma | 3-16 | at Alma26 | M. McGrady pass complete to Jeremy Stephens for 13 yards to the ALMA39 (Jared Thornton;Justin Hughes), PENALTY ALMA ineligible downfield on pass (Mike Bradburn) 5 yards to the ALMA21, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 3-21 | at Alma21 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 28 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma49 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Vinny Zanotti) 5 yards to the ALMA44. |
| Alma | 1-15 | at Alma44 | M. McGrady pass complete to Matt Brown for 31 yards to the OLIVET25, 1ST DOWN ALMA. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet25 | M. McGrady pass intercepted by Joe Cleveland at the OLIVET0, Joe Cleveland return 0 yards to the OLIVET0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 57 yards, TOP 03:20 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 05:06. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Mike Martin rush for 6 yards to the OLIVET26, out-of-bounds (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 2-4 | at Olivet26 | Mike Martin rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET28 (B. Scarborough). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Olivet28 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Carl Mulder for 7 yards to the OLIVET35, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (James Lang). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet35 | Mike Martin rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET40 (Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Olivet40 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Mike Martin for 6 yards to the OLIVET46, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet46 | Mike Martin rush for 4 yards to the 50 yardline (Bart Blystone;Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Olivet50 | Sean Misko rush for 3 yards to the ALMA47 (Zach Comer;James Young). |
| Olivet | 3-3 | at Alma47 | Nick McCleary rush for 2 yards to the ALMA45, out-of-bounds (James Young). |
| Olivet | 4-1 | at Alma45 | Sean Misko rush for 3 yards to the ALMA42, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma42 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Carl Mulder for 17 yards to the ALMA25, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (A.J. Rahar). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 55 yards, TOP 05:44 |
| | | Alma College 0, Olivet College 0 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma25 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma25 | Sean Misko rush for 12 yards to the ALMA13, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma13 | Mike Martin rush for 13 yards to the ALMA0, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:22. |
| | | Kyle Zabel kick attempt good. |
| | | Olivet College 7, Alma College 0 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 80 yards, TOP 05:44 |
| | | Kyle Zabel kickoff 40 yards to the ALMA30, Corey McCue return 12 yards to the ALMA42 (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma42 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 14:18. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma42 | M. McGrady pass complete to Jeremy Stephens for 11 yards to the OLIVET47, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet47 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 6 yards to the OLIVET41, out-of-bounds (Joe Cleveland), PENALTY ALMA illegal block (Jeremy Stephens) 10 yards to the ALMA49. |
| Alma | 1-14 | at Alma49 | 1st and 14. |
| Alma | 1-14 | at Alma49 | M. McGrady pass complete to Corey Wangler for 7 yards to the OLIVET44 (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Olivet44 | M. McGrady rush for 13 yards to the OLIVET31, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet31 | Tyler Periard rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET28, fumble forced by DeMario Akbar, fumble by Tyler Periard recovered by ALMA Andrew Schaar at OLIVET20, 1ST DOWN ALMA. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | M. McGrady sacked for loss of 7 yards to the OLIVET27 (Jesse Myers). |
| Alma | 2-17 | at Olivet27 | Tyler Periard rush for 16 yards to the OLIVET11 (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 3-1 | at Olivet11 | M. McGrady rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET7, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Britt Paige). |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet07 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Corey Wangler. |
| Alma | 2-G | at Olivet07 | Jon Reed rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:09. |
| | | Heath Laugal kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 7, Olivet College 7 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 58 yards, TOP 03:09 |
| | | Heath Laugal kickoff 62 yards to the OLIVET8, Mike Martin return 22 yards to the OLIVET30 (John Vance). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet30 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 11:03. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet30 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Nathaniel Woods for 19 yards to the OLIVET49, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (A.J. Rahar). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet49 | Pat Clasgens rush for 6 yards to the ALMA45 (Brad Collins). |
| Olivet | 2-4 | at Alma45 | Nick McCleary pass complete to James Williams for 10 yards to the ALMA35, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (A.J. Rahar). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma35 | Pat Clasgens rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA37 (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 2-12 | at Alma37 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Carl Mulder for 10 yards to the ALMA27 (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Alma27 | Sean Misko rush for no gain to the ALMA27 (Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 4-2 | at Alma27 | Pat Clasgens rush for 4 yards to the ALMA23, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Brent Willis). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma23 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to James Williams (Bart Blystone). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Alma23 | Timeout Alma College, clock 06:51. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Alma23 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to Pat Clasgens. |
| Olivet | 3-10 | at Alma23 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to Carl Mulder (Bart Blystone). |
| Olivet | 4-10 | at Alma23 | Kyle Zabel field goal attempt from 40 GOOD, clock 06:34. |
| | | Olivet College 10, Alma College 7 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 47 yards, TOP 04:29 |
| | | Kyle Zabel kickoff 50 yards to the ALMA20, Kyle Percival return 10 yards to the ALMA30, out-of-bounds (Nick Glass). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 06:26. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | Tyler Periard rush for 1 yard to the ALMA31 (Britt Paige). |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma31 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 8 yards to the ALMA39 (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 3-1 | at Alma39 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 7 yards to the ALMA46, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds (Jared Thornton). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma46 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 6 yards to the OLIVET48, out-of-bounds (Jared Thornton). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Olivet48 | M. McGrady pass complete to Corey Wangler for 14 yards to the OLIVET34, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet34 | Tyler Periard rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET30 (Anthony Silvas). |
| Alma | 2-6 | at Olivet30 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Matt Brown, dropped pass. |
| Alma | 3-6 | at Olivet30 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Jeremy Stephens, PENALTY ALMA holding declined. |
| Alma | 4-6 | at Olivet30 | M. McGrady pass complete to Tyler Periard for 9 yards to the OLIVET21, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Chris Behnke). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet21 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Matt Brown, QB hurry by Chris Gottardo. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet21 | M. McGrady rush for 10 yards to the OLIVET11, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds (Justin Hughes), PENALTY OLIVET personal foul (Justin Hughes) 5 yards to the OLIVET6, 1ST DOWN ALMA. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet06 | 1st and 6. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet06 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 02:31. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet06 | M. McGrady pass complete to Matt Brown for 6 yards to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:24. |
| | | Heath Laugal kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 14, Olivet College 10 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 70 yards, TOP 04:02 |
| | | Heath Laugal kickoff 60 yards to the OLIVET10, Mike Martin return 20 yards to the OLIVET30 (James Couture). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet30 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 02:18. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet30 | Pat Clasgens rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET33 (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 2-7 | at Olivet33 | Nick McCleary rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET37 (James Young). |
| Olivet | 3-3 | at Olivet37 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 4-3 | at Olivet37 | Ryan Patten punt 34 yards to the ALMA29, fair catch by Corey McCue. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma29 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 00:46. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma29 | M. McGrady pass incomplete, PENALTY ALMA illegal formation 5 yards to the ALMA24, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-15 | at Alma24 | M. McGrady pass complete to Corey Wangler for 8 yards to the ALMA32 (Nick Glass). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma32 | M. McGrady pass complete to Corey Wangler for 7 yards to the ALMA39, 1ST DOWN ALMA. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma39 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Kyle Percival. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma39 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Kyle Percival. |
| Alma | 3-10 | at Alma39 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Corey Wangler. |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Alma39 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:46 |
| | | Alma College 14, Olivet College 10 |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Alma39 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Alma39 | ALMA ball on ALMA30. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:46 |
| | | Heath Laugal kickoff 54 yards to the OLIVET16, Martise William return 4 yards to the OLIVET20. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 14:54. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Sean Misko for 15 yards to the OLIVET35, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Bart Blystone). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet35 | Pat Clasgens rush for 16 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (James Lang). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma49 | Pat Clasgens rush for 2 yards to the ALMA47 (Travis Martin;James Young). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Alma47 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to Pat Clasgens, dropped pass. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Alma47 | Nick McCleary sacked for loss of 7 yards to the OLIVET46 (James Young). |
| Olivet | 4-15 | at Olivet46 | Ryan Patten punt 37 yards to the ALMA17, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 26 yards, TOP 02:41 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma17 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 12:13. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma17 | Tyler Periard rush for 17 yards to the ALMA34, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Joe Cleveland;Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma34 | Jon Reed rush for 2 yards to the ALMA36 (William Albrech). |
| Alma | 2-8 | at Alma36 | M. McGrady rush for 5 yards to the ALMA41 (Justin Hughes). |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Alma41 | M. McGrady pass complete to Corey Wangler for 8 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma49 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Jeremy Stephens (DeMario Akbar). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma49 | Tyler Periard rush for loss of 3 yards to the ALMA46 (Hakeem Yakubu;Josh Haselton). |
| Alma | 3-13 | at Alma46 | M. McGrady pass complete to Jeremy Stephens for 19 yards to the OLIVET35, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Jared Thornton). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet35 | Tyler Periard rush for 13 yards to the OLIVET22, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet22 | Tyler Periard rush for 12 yards to the OLIVET10, 1ST DOWN ALMA (DeMario Akbar;Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet10 | M. McGrady rush for 10 yards to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:10. |
| | | Heath Laugal kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 21, Olivet College 10 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 83 yards, TOP 04:03 |
| | | Heath Laugal kickoff 40 yards to the OLIVET30, Mike Martin return 3 yards to the OLIVET33 (Vinny Zanotti). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet33 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:06. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet33 | Pat Clasgens rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET40 (Bart Blystone;B. Scarborough). |
| Olivet | 2-3 | at Olivet40 | Pat Clasgens rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET41 (Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Olivet41 | Pat Clasgens rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET48, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Bart Blystone;Nick Merlo). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet48 | Sean Misko rush for 2 yards to the 50 yardline (TEAM). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Olivet50 | Nick McCleary rush for 4 yards to the ALMA46. |
| Olivet | 3-4 | at Alma46 | Pat Clasgens rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALMA47 (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 4-5 | at Alma47 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 04:18. |
| Olivet | 4-5 | at Alma47 | Nick McCleary pass intercepted by James Lang at the ALMA20, James Lang return 0 yards to the ALMA20. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 20 yards, TOP 03:55 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma20 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 04:11. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma20 | Tyler Periard rush for 1 yard to the ALMA21 (Hakeem Yakubu;William Albrech). |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma21 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Corey Wangler (Jared Thornton), PENALTY OLIVET offside defense (William Albrech) 5 yards to the ALMA26, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma26 | Tyler Periard rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALMA25, out-of-bounds (Joe Cleveland). |
| Alma | 3-5 | at Alma25 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Matt Brown. |
| Alma | 4-5 | at Alma25 | Matt Brown punt 18 yards to the ALMA43, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:30 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma43 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 02:41. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma43 | Mike Martin rush for 4 yards to the ALMA39 (B. Scarborough). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Alma39 | Nick McCleary pass complete to James Williams for 1 yard to the ALMA38, out-of-bounds (Eric Jobe). |
| Olivet | 3-5 | at Alma38 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to Lauren Milligan (John Vance). |
| Olivet | 4-5 | at Alma38 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Carl Mulder for 12 yards to the ALMA26, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Bart Blystone;Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma26 | Pat Clasgens rush for 1 yard to the ALMA25 (Brad Collins). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Alma25 | Nick McCleary pass incomplete to Nathaniel Woods (James Lang), PENALTY ALMA pass interference (James Lang) 7 yards to the ALMA18, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma18 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 00:17. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma18 | Sean Misko rush for 11 yards to the ALMA7, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 36 yards, TOP 03:27 |
| | | Alma College 21, Olivet College 10 |
| Olivet | 1-G | at Alma07 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Olivet | 1-G | at Alma07 | Nick McCleary rush for 2 yards to the ALMA5 (Eric Jobe). |
| Olivet | 2-G | at Alma05 | Sean Misko rush for 5 yards to the ALMA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:14. |
| | | Kyle Zabel kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 21, Olivet College 17 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 43 yards, TOP 03:27 |
| | | Kyle Zabel kickoff 40 yards to the ALMA30, Corey McCue return 10 yards to the ALMA40 (Cody Worden), PENALTY ALMA illegal block (James Couture) 10 yards to the ALMA30, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on ALMA30. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 14:07. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma30 | Tyler Periard rush for 3 yards to the ALMA33 (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma33 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Corey Wangler. |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Alma33 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Andrew Schaar. |
| Alma | 4-7 | at Alma33 | Matt Brown punt 42 yards to the OLIVET25, fair catch by Carl Mulder. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet25 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 13:12. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet25 | Nick McCleary pass intercepted by Brad Collins at the OLIVET21, Brad Collins return 0 yards to the OLIVET21. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:04 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet21 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 13:08. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet21 | M. McGrady pass complete to Jeremy Stephens for 3 yards to the OLIVET18 (Michael Terrano). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Olivet18 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Andrew Schaar. |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Olivet18 | M. McGrady pass complete to Andrew Schaar for 18 yards to the OLIVET0, 1ST DOWN ALMA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:15. |
| | | Heath Laugal kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 28, Olivet College 17 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 21 yards, TOP 00:53 |
| | | Heath Laugal kickoff 57 yards to the OLIVET13, Brandon Medlen return 14 yards to the OLIVET27 (Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet27 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 12:09. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet27 | Pat Clasgens rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET30 (B. Scarborough;Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 2-7 | at Olivet30 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Nathaniel Woods for 10 yards to the OLIVET40, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet40 | Pat Clasgens rush for 13 yards to the ALMA47, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Bart Blystone). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma47 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Mike Martin for 44 yards to the ALMA3, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (James Lang). |
| Olivet | 1-G | at Alma03 | Sean Misko rush for 1 yard to the ALMA2 (James Young). |
| Olivet | 2-G | at Alma02 | Nick McCleary rush for 1 yard to the ALMA1 (Jacob Zainea). |
| Olivet | 3-G | at Alma01 | Mike Martin rush for 1 yard to the ALMA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:24. |
| | | Nick McCleary pass attempt to Nathaniel Woods good, PENALTY ALMA holding declined. |
| | | Alma College 28, Olivet College 25 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 73 yards, TOP 03:45 |
| | | Kyle Zabel kickoff 40 yards to the ALMA30, Aaron Sprague return 28 yards to the OLIVET42 (Kyle Zabel). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet42 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 08:15. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet42 | Tyler Periard rush for no gain to the OLIVET42 (Justin Hughes). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet42 | M. McGrady pass incomplete to Corey Wangler, QB hurry by Justin Hughes. |
| Alma | 3-10 | at Olivet42 | M. McGrady sacked for loss of 18 yards to the ALMA40 (Hakeem Yakubu). |
| Alma | 4-28 | at Alma40 | Timeout Alma College, clock 06:45. |
| Alma | 4-28 | at Alma40 | Matt Brown punt 32 yards to the OLIVET28, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 18 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 06:36. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | Pat Clasgens rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET30, out-of-bounds (A.J. Rahar). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Olivet30 | Pat Clasgens rush for 30 yards to the ALMA40, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (A.J. Rahar). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma40 | Pat Clasgens rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALMA41 (Zach Comer). |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Alma41 | Nick McCleary pass complete to James Williams for 6 yards to the ALMA35 (Eric Jobe). |
| Olivet | 3-5 | at Alma35 | Pat Clasgens rush for 8 yards to the ALMA27, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (John Vance). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma27 | Nick McCleary pass complete to Carl Mulder for 11 yards to the ALMA16, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma16 | Mike Martin rush for no gain to the ALMA16 (Travis Martin). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Alma16 | Nick McCleary pass intercepted by Travis Martin at the ALMA0, Travis Martin return 0 yards to the ALMA0, touchback, PENALTY ALMA unsportsmanlike conduct (Travis Martin) 10 yards to the ALMA10, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on ALMA10. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 56 yards, TOP 04:07 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma10 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 02:29. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma10 | Tyler Periard rush for 12 yards to the ALMA22, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma22 | M. McGrady rush for 8 yards to the ALMA30 (DeMario Akbar). |
| Alma | 2-2 | at Alma30 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 01:32. |
| Alma | 2-2 | at Alma30 | M. McGrady rush for 11 yards to the ALMA41, 1ST DOWN ALMA (William Albrech). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma41 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA39. |
| Alma | 2-12 | at Alma39 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 29 yards, TOP 02:29 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Alma College 28, Olivet College 25 |